Lawmakers, advocates push for breast cancer screening bill
National News
Audio By Carbonatix
2:19 PM on Wednesday, November 18
Andrew Rice
(The Center Square) - Lawmakers and advocates are pushing for legislation to lower costs of breast cancer screenings and assist women’s health care initiatives, which advocates acknowledge would raise health care premiums for Americans.
U.S. Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, D-N.Y., and Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meeks, R-Iowa, said the next Congress should focus on women’s health and on lowering barriers for early screening.
“Women still need to build power in this country,” Gillibrand said. “They’re not listened to. Their healthcare isn’t invested in.”
Gillibrand and Miller-Meeks pushed for passage of the Access to Breast Cancer Diagnosis Act, which would require insurance plans to cover diagnostic and supplemental breast cancer screening tests without co-pays.
The Susan G. Komen Foundation, a breast cancer awareness organization, estimates that diagnostic imaging for breast cancer costs between $234 and $1,041. Miller-Meeks said the legislation would work to bring that cost down.
“Too often we wait until symptoms develop, which is why the multi-cancer early detection and early screening is important,” Miller-Meeks said. “It's not just elderly people who may develop cancer, but younger people and letting them have access to screening, which requires a change in healthcare policy and healthcare coverage.”
Amber Guild, president and CEO of the Susan G. Komen Foundation, praised the bill and said her struggle with breast cancer was helped by the fact that she had early detection.
Breast cancer that is diagnosed before it spreads beyond the breast has a five-year survival rate of more than 99%, according to the American Cancer Society.
“What we're looking to do is figure out what are the ways they add up,” Guild said. “Why would we not do everything we can to then make sure that we have early detection?”
Advocacy organizations acknowledged the legislation could raise premiums if insurers are required to cover more screening procedures. Advocates with the Alliance for Women's Health and Prevention said 36 states have implemented assistance for these screening methods with little impact on insurance premiums.
"These bills expand affordable access to needed breast imaging, seeking earlier detection and timely treatment at every stage of breast cancer, reducing the impact of breast cancer on the patient, health care system and society with little impact on insurance premiums," advocates wrote in a letter to lawmakers.
The Congressional Budget Office has not assessed the legislation's effect on insurance premiums.
Gillibrand also called for advancements in early detection technology. She said most diagnostic tools are intimidating for women and can prevent patients from seeking necessary care.
“The current state of the art medical advice is to take a massive needle, shove it into your breast, take four or five chunks out of your breast and test it,” Gillibrand said. “That seems barbaric to me.”
She said greater investment in research and screening tools would dramatically change the approach to women’s health.
Miller-Meeks agreed that lawmakers should focus on innovative approaches to diagnose and test for cancer in women. She called for greater focus on breast cancer screenings among young women by making procedures more affordable.
Women under 50 saw an increased incidence rate of breast cancer compared with older women, according to the Breast Cancer Research Foundation. The foundation also reports that breast cancer is the leading cause of cancer death among women ages 20 to 49.
“Their doctor or their provider can help guide them to where they need to go next, depending upon what their risk is,” Miller-Meeks said. “I think we've made progress, that doesn't mean that we stop.”